
UpTrajectory Review
Alison Green addresses a problem many small-business owners face but few discuss openly: employees who exploit disability accommodations. The piece handles three workplace scenarios, each illustrating the tension between genuine legal obligation to accommodate disabilities and the risk that someone will claim accommodation as cover for poor performance or policy violation. Green's framing is crucial—she does not assume bad faith, but she does acknowledge that abuse happens, and that owners need practical tools to distinguish between legitimate need and manipulation without crossing into discrimination.
For a small-business operator, this matters immediately. Disability accommodations are legally protected under the ADA, but that protection does not mean every accommodation request is valid, nor does it mean you must accept every excuse offered by an employee. Your exposure runs in both directions: deny a genuine accommodation and face a lawsuit; grant an illegitimate one and watch it metastasize into precedent and resentment among other staff. The stakes feel higher in a small firm because you lack an HR department to absorb the legal and administrative burden. One misstep can consume weeks of your time and thousands in legal fees.
The genuinely useful insight Green offers is procedural rather than philosophical. She walks through how to respond when an employee cites a disability to avoid, say, a performance improvement plan or a return-to-office mandate. The key is not to deny accommodation outright, but to require documentation, to consult with employment counsel, and to distinguish between the accommodation itself (which you may need to grant) and the employee's proposed solution (which may not be the only way to accommodate, or may not accommodate at all). This is the part small-business owners most often get wrong—they either rubber-stamp requests out of fear, or they flatly refuse them out of frustration. Green's middle path is where the law actually lives.
The second-order effects cut deep. Granting a sham accommodation signals to your legitimate staff that the rules are negotiable if you invoke the right language. It also invites more claims, each harder to evaluate because you have set no precedent for rigor. Conversely, a culture of skepticism toward accommodation requests chills legitimate requests and exposes you to hostile-work-environment claims from employees with genuine disabilities who see the company as hostile. The cost is not just legal; it is retention and morale. Strong performers with real disabilities will leave rather than fight you.
Watch for the documentation step. When an employee requests accommodation, your response should be consistent: ask for medical certification that explains the functional limitation and how the proposed accommodation addresses it. Consult a local employment attorney before you proceed, not after you have already said yes or no. Do not assume the employee's proposed accommodation is the only one, or even the right one. A disability might require flexibility, but not necessarily the specific form the employee requested. Test your accommodation against the actual job requirements, not against your discomfort with saying no.
Takeaway: Require medical documentation before granting any disability accommodation and consult employment counsel before you commit.
Excerpt from the original — Inc. Magazine
And two other tricky workplace dilemmas.